Why don’t perpetual motion machines ever work?

perpetual motion machines
Perpetual Motion Machines

Do you know why perpetual motion machines don’t ever work? In the medieval period, a mathematician named Bhaskara the Learned envisioned an innovative idea – a wheel that could keep spinning indefinitely due to an imbalance created by mercury flowing within it. This sketch was the inception of the fascinating concept of perpetual motion machines – devices that could work indefinitely without an external source of energy.

The Hypothetical Impact

A successful perpetual motion machine could transform the world. Think of a windmill generating the wind it needs to keep spinning, or a lightbulb illuminating itself. If these machines were to include humans as part of their system, life could be sustained indefinitely. However, reality paints a different picture – these devices don’t work. They violate the fundamental laws of thermodynamics, governing energy forms and their interrelation.

The First Law of Thermodynamics: Energy Conservation

The primary barrier in the path of these innovative machines is the first law of thermodynamics – the principle of energy conservation. It asserts that you cannot extract more energy than what you invest – invalidating the utility of a perpetual motion machine right off the bat. It could only generate as much energy as it consumes, leaving nothing to power a car or charge a phone.

Plenty of ideas have been suggested to circumvent this law, but all have met with failure. Take, for example, the over-balanced wheel concept. Moving parts meant to make one side of the wheel heavier inadvertently shift its center of mass downward, causing it to swing back and forth like a pendulum before coming to a standstill.

Alternative Approaches and Their Downfalls

Inventors have also explored other approaches, like Robert Boyle’s idea of a self-watering pot using capillary action. However, if capillary action could overcome gravity and draw the water up, it would also inhibit it from falling back into the bowl.

Magnet-based machines have been suggested as well, envisioning a ball being pulled up by a magnet and then falling back down to repeat the cycle. But this design is similarly flawed – the magnet would simply hold the ball at the top, and even if it did keep moving, the magnet’s strength would degrade over time.

The Second Law of Thermodynamics: Energy Dispersal

Even if a design managed to sidestep the first law, it would still fall victim to the second law of thermodynamics, stating that energy tends to disperse. Real machines invariably generate tiny amounts of friction and heat due to moving parts or interactions with air or liquid molecules. This heat represents escaping energy, continually reducing the machine’s energy until it grinds to a halt.

Future Prospects and the Quest for Understanding

The laws of thermodynamics have continually thwarted attempts at creating perpetual motion machines and the utopia of perfectly efficient energy generation they symbolize. Yet, it would be unscientific to say definitively that we’ll never discover such a machine.

Our understanding of the universe still has many gaps. There could be new, foreign forms of matter that might lead us to reconsider the laws of thermodynamics. Or, perhaps, perpetual motion exists on tiny quantum scales.

For now, the one thing that does seem truly perpetual is our relentless search for knowledge and understanding. This search is the heart of scientific discovery, continually pushing us to challenge established laws and venture into the unknown.

This insightful video on the conundrum of perpetual motion machines serves as a reminder of our scientific journey so far and the immense potential for future discovery. I would strongly recommend it to students, enthusiasts, and anyone curious about the fascinating world of physics. After all, who knows what breakthrough might be around the corner?


YouTube Video: Why don’t perpetual motion machines ever work? – Netta Schramm

Why don’t perpetual motion machines ever work? – Netta Schramm

Other Stories

Why kids don’t get as cold as adults do
A Plan Is Not a Strategy: A Summary of HBR
A Peek Inside the Atom: The Proton’s Story

Leave a Reply